erwer

Gerry McCann Calls For Post-Leveson Press Control Legislation

As news comes this week that Gerry and Madeleine McCann’s former lawyer has received a suspended sentence for deliberately flouting legal undertakings not to repeat allegations about the couple, Gerry McCann has called for press control laws.

Mr Justice Tugendhat, in the High Court yesterday, said that the conduct of retired solicitor Tony Bennett was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months, suspended for one year, would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge said that he was sure that Bennett had intended to allege that the claimants were to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, disposing of her body, lying about what had happened and covering up what they had done.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said he was satisfied that Bennett was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court, out of 153 publications complained about.

Meanwhile, Dr McCann has called for speedy legislation to implement the recommendations made by Lord Justice Leveson at the end of his nine-month inquiry.

Maintaining that “Leveson without the law is meaningless”, Dr McCann spoke of the “assault” he and his wife had suffered at the hands of the press when they threw “everything they had” at the couple.

He added that the only reason he and his wife went through the ordeal of giving evidence at the Leveson enquiry was so that no one else would have to suffer as they did.

Other supporters of press legislation were heartened recently when peers unexpectedly passed an amendment to the Defamation Bill to introduce one of Leveson’s key recommendations, which is a simple arbitration service between newspapers and those who feel wronged by them.

Use of the service would be voluntary and form part of the newspaper industry’s own self-regulatory system, but the amendment would allow courts to vary costs and damages depending on whether the service has been used.
MPs and ministers who do not wish to accept the Lords amendment will now have to overturn the planned legislation in the Commons.

Batman Wins Again

The Intellectual Property Office Adjudicator has ruled that a British sound design company that wanted to trademark several of its cricket-related products under the name Batsman may not do so in case the public confuses them with the comic book superhero.

The Adjudicator refused to grant a trademark for the name to London-based Adelphoi Ltd and ruled in favour of DC Comics, the US entertainment giants who own the Batman trademark.

In his ruling, the judge accepted that ‘Batman is a very well known comic book character’, first invented in 1939. However, despite accepting that there is a ‘conceptual dissonance’ between Batman and Batsman, described as ‘a type of cricketer or an aircraft safety officer’, he found that the two words ‘may easily be mistaken for one another’.

He added that the marks look and sound so close that the difference in concept is likely to go unnoticed and if the difference goes unnoticed then the conceptual difference has no material effect, leading to a ‘likelihood of confusion’.

Referring to the evidence presented by DC Comics, the adjudicator said they relied on the European trademark in the Batman name and the goodwill stemming from the use of the mark in relation to comics, films, television programmes and “a wide variety of merchandise”.

He said that Batman has appeared in thousands of comic books, with global sales figures ranging from around $6m to $12m per year between 2001 and 2007.

In addition, Batman Begins grossed over £30m in the UK, and its sequel, The Dark Knight “appears to have been even more popular, and had sold more than 2.5 million copies on Blu-ray and DVD by December 2008”. The judge also detailed almost $20m in merchandising sales in the UK between 1998 and 2011.

However, he declined to order Adelphoi to pay DC’s legal costs, finding that DC’s lawyers could have been “more measured in their approach” and provided less evidence to support its case than the eight lever arch files they put in.

Whistleblowing Laws To Be Overhauled

In a private letter sent to MPs and Peers last week, Employment Relations Minister Jo Swinson said that whistleblowing legislation will be overhauled and promised amendments to the Public Interest Disclosure Act (Pida) 1998.

The letter came after a second whistleblower claimed that the head of the NHS had ignored written warnings about failings in a hospital trust, which is being investigated for persistently high death rates.

Former chairman of United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust (ULHT), David Bowles, said he had sent a letter in July 2009 to the Chief Executive of the NHS, Sir David Nicholson, warning that patients could die there because managers were being forced to meet unrealistic targets. He claimed that Nicholson failed to investigate the detailed allegations properly.

While last week, Gary Walker, the former Chief Executive of ULHT, claimed that he was gagged, threatened and prevented from raising patient safety concerns, which was condemned by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt, who said that if it were found to be true, it would be unacceptable.

Ms Swinson’s letter refers to a recent meeting between Lords Younger, Young and Stevenson in which “the possibility of taking a wider look” at Pida was discussed. This, she added, could happen after the enterprise and regulatory reform bill returns to parliament later this month.

She wrote that “consideration” will then be given to how the Act “might” be extended to some NHS workers not currently covered by Pida and that those discussions will be followed by a consultation on “other issues, such as the need to protect job applicants who have suffered because they were blacklisted for blowing the whistle

However, Sir Richard Shepherd, the Conservative MP who introduced Pida as a private member’s bill in 1998, said it needed no amendments. He said he was “angered” by the criticisms of what he described as “one of the most progressive Acts in the western world”.